When Aston Villa announce their teams at Villa Park, Emiliano Martínez is proudly introduced as the world’s number one goalkeeper. It is a title the club embraces, reflecting his status as a World Cup winner with Argentina and a two-time recipient of the prestigious Yashin Trophy, awarded to the best goalkeeper on the planet.
Yet despite those accolades, Martínez’s position at Aston Villa is under increasing scrutiny. Since a potential move to Manchester United collapsed at the end of the summer transfer window, the 33-year-old has found himself at the centre of growing debate about his form and long-term future.
At first glance, the criticism seems puzzling. Villa are currently third in the Premier League and have reached the Europa League last 16, exceeding expectations and pushing into the title conversation. Martínez recently marked his 200th Premier League appearance for the club in Sunday’s 2-0 victory at Newcastle, a match that also saw him register his 59th clean sheet for Villa.
But beneath the surface, costly errors have crept into his performances at key moments, threatening to undermine Villa’s momentum. While Martínez remains one of the most decorated goalkeepers in world football, this season has presented challenges that suggest he may be approaching a crossroads in his Villa career.
Questions after the Old Trafford move collapsed
It is difficult to pinpoint exactly why Martínez has appeared less dominant this season, but many observers link the dip in form to his failed transfer to Manchester United.
After Villa’s final home match of last season against Tottenham in May, Martínez cut an emotional figure, appearing to wave goodbye to supporters. The club were open to letting him leave, and potential replacements, including Brentford’s Mark Flekken, were considered. However, Manchester United ultimately opted against signing him.
United manager Ruben Amorim reportedly pushed for the Argentine’s arrival, but the club’s recruitment team favoured Belgian goalkeeper Senne Lammens instead. Data analysis suggested Lammens had the potential to become one of Europe’s top keepers, making him a more financially sustainable and long-term option. United prioritised strengthening their attack, investing in players such as Matheus Cunha, Benjamin Sesko and Bryan Mbeumo, while Lammens arrived from Royal Antwerp.
On 31 August, the day before the transfer deadline, Martínez was left out of Villa’s 3-0 home defeat to Crystal Palace. When asked about his absence, head coach Unai Emery repeatedly referenced backup goalkeeper Marco Bizot, offering little clarity. Martínez returned after the international break in a goalless draw at Everton on 13 September, with Emery publicly reaffirming his faith, calling him “the best goalkeeper in the world” and praising his commitment to the club.
Are the numbers really the problem?
Statistically, Martínez’s season is far from disastrous. He has saved 76.1% of the shots he has faced, the highest save percentage in the Premier League. He ranks fifth in Opta’s “goals prevented” metric with 17 and has made 55 saves, placing him 12th among league goalkeepers.
Villa have conceded 25 goals in the league, but eight of those came with Bizot in goal. Martínez’s expected goals on target conceded stands at 20.85, suggesting his overall shot-stopping remains strong.
However, one figure stands out uncomfortably: three errors leading directly to goals — the highest total in the Premier League this season. These mistakes, more than his general play, have fuelled doubts.
High-profile errors under the spotlight
The most glaring error came in November at Anfield, when Martínez miscontrolled possession and gifted Mohamed Salah a simple goal, setting Liverpool on their way to a 2-0 victory. Although Villa responded impressively by winning 11 consecutive matches afterwards, the incident lingered in the memory.
Further scrutiny followed in Villa’s 4-1 defeat to Arsenal on 30 December. Martínez spilled the ball under pressure from Gabriel at a corner, allowing the defender to score. Villa protested, arguing that the goal should have been ruled out due to a high elbow, but the damage was done.
Most recently, his handling error against Everton proved decisive. Failing to gather or clear Dwight McNeil’s shot, Martínez allowed Thierno Barry to score the winner, prompting renewed debate over his reliability.
Martínez missed Villa’s 1-0 Europa League win away to Fenerbahce with a calf injury, during which Bizot kept his fifth clean sheet in 11 appearances this season. While Bizot, 34, is not viewed as a long-term successor, his performances have inevitably raised questions.
Confidence, pressure and the goalkeeper’s mindset
Former England goalkeeper Paul Robinson has expressed sympathy for Martínez, highlighting the psychological demands of the position.
“Goalkeeping is all about confidence,” Robinson explained. “You’re the first to know when something isn’t right. You have to project calm and authority, even when inside you’re struggling. It’s a lonely role.”
Robinson compared fluctuations in confidence to changes in perception: “Sometimes the ball looks like a beach ball; sometimes it looks like a golf ball.”
Martínez, Robinson believes, may not be as settled as he once was. Persistent speculation over his future, combined with the disappointment of the United move falling through, may have subtly affected his focus.
What comes next for Martínez and Villa?
Martínez remains Villa’s undisputed number one and is under contract until 2029. However, he has been linked with a move to Inter Milan, and Villa are expected to reassess his future during the summer.
Despite the doubts, his quality is not in question. He has made 234 appearances for Villa since arriving from Arsenal for £17m in 2020 and has been instrumental in the club’s rise. But as Villa push to establish themselves among Europe’s elite, the margin for error grows smaller.
As Robinson concluded: “He’s a top-quality goalkeeper. Whether he’s still among the very best in the world is open to debate. If Villa want to move him on — or if he wants to leave — replacing him will not be easy.”
For now, Martínez continues as Emery’s first choice, but with speculation unlikely to fade, the coming months may define the next chapter of his career.
🔗 Read more: https://netsports247.com
