Michael Carrick Impresses During Interim Manchester United Spell as Club Weighs Long-Term Decision
Michael Carrick has enjoyed a remarkable start to his second period as Manchester United’s head coach, producing three consecutive victories against some of the Premier League’s most respected managers. Wins over Pep Guardiola, Mikel Arteta, and Marco Silva have immediately transformed the mood at Old Trafford, with United now pushing strongly for a top-four finish and Champions League qualification next season.
Just weeks ago, fears were growing that United could miss out on European football for the second year running. Carrick’s early success has quickly changed that outlook, sparking debates among fans and pundits about whether he deserves the job on a permanent basis. However, while enthusiasm is building externally, the club itself remains cautious and committed to a careful and structured hiring process.
United Determined to Follow Structured Recruitment Plan
When Manchester United dismissed Ruben Amorim on 5 January, senior figures within the club stressed their intention to follow a detailed and professional selection process before appointing a new full-time manager. According to individuals familiar with the situation, that strategy has not changed despite Carrick’s strong results.
United’s leadership believes that rushing into a long-term decision based solely on short-term success could lead to complications later. The club is keen to ensure they evaluate all possible candidates thoroughly before making a final call.
Lessons Learned from the Solskjaer Appointment
Manchester United’s cautious approach is heavily influenced by past experience, particularly the appointment of Ole Gunnar Solskjaer in 2018.
After Jose Mourinho’s departure, Solskjaer was initially hired as a temporary manager until the end of the season. The Norwegian quickly energized the squad and delivered outstanding results, winning his first eight matches. That run included major victories against Tottenham in the Premier League and Arsenal in the FA Cup.
Although Solskjaer suffered a Champions League defeat against Paris Saint-Germain during that spell, United famously overturned the result with a historic comeback victory in Paris. That triumph convinced the club to offer him a three-year contract shortly afterward.
However, fatigue and tactical challenges soon emerged. United won just two of their final twelve matches that season, raising concerns that the club had acted too quickly in making Solskjaer’s appointment permanent. Many believe that if United had waited until the summer to assess all available candidates, the outcome might have been different.
While Sir Jim Ratcliffe now oversees football operations at the club, the Solskjaer example remains a significant reminder of the risks associated with rushed managerial decisions.
Upcoming Managerial Availability Adds Complexity
Another major reason United may delay announcing a permanent manager is the possibility that several high-quality candidates could become available in the near future.
Within the Premier League, Oliver Glasner, Andoni Iraola, and Marco Silva are all regarded as respected coaches. Glasner, in particular, built a strong reputation by winning the Europa League with Eintracht Frankfurt and later guiding Crystal Palace to their first major trophy by defeating Manchester City in the FA Cup final last season. Palace also claimed the Community Shield shortly afterward.
Despite those achievements, Glasner has struggled this season. Palace endured a twelve-match winless run and suffered a surprising FA Cup defeat against lower-league Macclesfield. Their inconsistent form has left them sitting 15th in the league table, casting doubt over Glasner’s long-term future at the club.
These fluctuations highlight how rapidly a manager’s reputation can shift based on results, reinforcing United’s decision to conduct a comprehensive search.
International Coaches Also Under Consideration
Manchester United’s search may extend beyond club football. Several high-profile international managers could also emerge as potential candidates after major tournaments.
England manager Thomas Tuchel has already held discussions with United in the past, particularly during deliberations about Erik ten Hag’s position. Meanwhile, Mauricio Pochettino, currently managing the United States national team, has long been linked with the Old Trafford job.
Other internationally respected coaches such as Carlo Ancelotti (Brazil) and Julian Nagelsmann (Germany) could also become options depending on future circumstances.
However, hiring an international manager around a major tournament like the World Cup presents unique challenges. Historical examples show that negotiating agreements with national team coaches during tournaments can create significant controversy and destabilize both the coach and their current team.
Experts suggest that while informal discussions are common in football, finalizing contracts before major international competitions can damage reputations and create unnecessary distractions.
Balancing Long-Term Planning with Carrick’s Momentum
While Manchester United carefully assess external candidates, Carrick continues to deliver results on the pitch. His calm leadership style and familiarity with the club have helped maintain squad morale despite ongoing uncertainty.
Some players, however, may prefer clarity regarding the club’s managerial direction. Defender Harry Maguire is approaching the end of his contract, and United are also targeting several midfield reinforcements, including Elliott Anderson, Adam Wharton, and Carlos Baleba. Potential signings may wish to know who will be leading the team before committing their future to the club.
Historically, managerial uncertainty has caused problems for United. During the 2021-22 season, interim manager Ralf Rangnick struggled to maintain stability, with the team winning only five of their final nineteen matches and suffering a disappointing FA Cup exit against Middlesbrough.
Carrick, however, remains confident that similar issues will not arise during his tenure.
“I have no concerns,” Carrick recently said. “The players have responded incredibly well. Everyone understands the bigger picture, but as professionals, we focus on performing and achieving our goals.”
Carrick’s Short-Term Success Still Faces Long-Term Questions
Even if Carrick’s interim spell ends at the conclusion of the season, his potential 17-game tenure would not rank among the shortest managerial reigns in Premier League history. For comparison, Ange Postecoglou’s brief stint at Nottingham Forest earlier this season lasted only five matches.
Manchester United now face a delicate balancing act between rewarding Carrick’s impressive performances and ensuring they select the best long-term candidate to guide the club back to consistent success at both domestic and European levels.
With expectations rising and the race for Champions League qualification intensifying, Carrick’s performances over the coming months could significantly influence the club’s final decision.
For more football news, transfer updates, and match analysis, visit
👉 https://netsports247.com
